Course timing and readings

** Your EETT Group Project Date has been moved to Sunday Night, October 19th. We want those uploaded to the appropriate section on Blackboard. However, we also want a printed copy delivered at the start of class on Tuesday, October 21st. Be sure all group member names are on it. * * *

We’ll be the Valuation Section of the course and will be discussing how to break up valuations across market and non-market values, the different components of non-market valuation, a further examination of risk analysis, and then moving on to illustrate different methods on the ground to elicit non-market valuation. Finally, we will discuss the meaning of applying dollar valuations to human lives themselves.

Assignments and due dates

Note that you do NOT have an assignment due over the Fall Break. Use that time to rest and enjoy, and of course make more progress on your EETT projects.

We do have an assignment due on the 19th, and that is already posted. Caitlin and the TAs WILL also be hosting discussion sessions after we return from break.

Course projects

EETT Submission Option: While we still prefer you to write your EETT out (think about the intention of the project, surely you’d want to hand a “white paper” to your target audience) we are also offering the following option.

  • If your group wishes instead to have a discussion about the EETT, we will accept a discussion.
  • Include an audio recording of your discussion (making sure again that audio levels are satisfactory), AND…
  • A short (less than 10 minutes) presentation to your peers, during which time we will have you receive feedback from them AND you are to also record that conversation and add to your assignment submission.
  • Caitlin and the TA team have organized discussion sessions on October 22nd and 24th.
  • Session One: Wednesday, October 22nd from 7:40-8:30pm in Bausch and Lomb 106
  • Session Two: Friday, October 24th from 11:50-12:40 in Meliora 205
  • Please refer to her announcements to determine which session you will be presenting in. It would be lovely if you would attend both.

EETT Advice: Use Economics! Frame the questions. Always ask where the tradeoffs are. If your group has met and has an outline, but feels an extension is warranted in order to make it excellent, send me a note with a description of your work and why you’d like the extension. Note I am not on email this weekend.

Group Project Cheat Sheet

We have THREE group experiences in lieu of quizzes and exams.

  • 1. Get Outside Project:
  • a. Due November 4th.
  • b. Group size between 4 and 8.
  • 2. EETT (this is part one of a two-part engagement experience)
  • a. Reflection 1: due as part of Week 3 RRR (Sept 14th)
  • b. Reflection 2: due as part of Week 4 RRR (Sept 21st)
  • c. Individual EETT Submission: due Sept 25th
  • d. Group Precis: due Oct 5th
  • e. Final Project: due Oct 19th
  • f. Group size between 4 and 8
  • 3. Interview Project (this is part two of a two-part engagement experience)
  • a. Project due December 11th
  • b. Group size between 4 and 8

Other class administration and availability

TA Office Hours and Info Look for an announcement from our Head TA Cailtin Lipton for an update.

  • The TAs are continue to offer office hours and weekly discussion sessions which will enable you to explore class topics more deeply, and to dive into portions of the weekly class work (and possibly receive credit for doing so). No discussion session next week.

My Availability: For the most up to date info on my office hours availability, and campus whereabouts and other ways (possibly) to meet and get in touch with me, check our Office Hours Blackboard page at tiny.cc/RizzoHours. I also post some job info on there and other items to discuss.

Office hours are a great place to bring your EETT group to bounce ideas off of me, and I am happy to help you all get a baseline start on the topics you are interested in.

Please stop by our picnic lunch bunches on Mondays and Wednesdays from 11:30am to 12:45pm, they’ve been fun. Meet new people! Talk to my freshmen! This week, Wednesday’s hours will begin at 4:15pm and we will walk over together to the Margo talk.

I will be out in the Pioneer Valley over break mostly out of phone contact.

Upcoming Special Events

Department of Economics Engerman Lecture

Who: Robert Margo of Boston University

When: Wednesday, October 15th

Time: 5:00pm

Where: Morey 321

What: From the Artisan Shop to the Mechanized Factory: Inanimate Power and the Transformation of American Manufacturing, 1820 to 1900

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

The Politics and Markets Project, Hosted by Professor David Primo

Title: Topic TBD (this will be a moderated panel discussion, likely on immigration)

Date: Wednesday, November 5th

Time: 7:30pm to 8:30pm

Location: Wegmans Hall, 1400.

The Department of Economics will be hosting several additional events this fall, TBA, coming soon!

Expected Guests/Topics: Paul Bloom on Empathy/Compassion; David Livingstone-Smith (philosopher); Victor Haghani (money manager)

Some Things That Captured Our Attention

It Must Be the Logo: “Harvard University is one of the most difficult schools to gain admission to, with the school turning away some 97 percent of applicants every year. But once they get in, many of its students skip class and fail to do the reading, according to the Classroom Social Compact Committee, a group of seven faculty members that produced a report on Harvard’s classroom culture that has been fueling debate since it was released in January. When they do show up for class, they are focused on their devices, and are reluctant to speak out. Sometimes it is because they are afraid of sharing ideas that others will disagree with. But often, they have not read enough of the homework to make a meaningful contribution, the report continued. Rampant grade inflation allows them to coast through anyway, it concluded. That means many students graduate without having benefited from talking very much with their teachers and peers, and they stay stuck in ideological bubbles, unwilling or unable to engage with challenging ideas”

The Mother of All Externalities? Nightmare bacteria.

The Ozone Layer Marches Onward: 2024 healing edition.

A Dead Cat Thwarts the Blue Angels? 57: “Yassine’s cat to death; in response, Yassine and his family posted profanity-laden rants on the Blue Angels’ Instagram page. Whoever ran the account deleted the rants - but Yassine is a lawyer, and knew that First Amendment law says that government-affiliated bodies cannot moderate / selectively delete comments. He sued, his dramatically-written lawsuit went viral, and he takes partial credit for the Blue Angels being a little quieter this year. I’m split on this: I just really hate noise, and I’m happy to see anyone who makes it lose lawsuits. But I’m also not sure who it serves to make all government-affiliated webpages close their comment

sections because they don’t want to have to keep profanity-laced rants up and they’re not allowed to selectively moderate. My strongest opinion on this matter is that Yassine’s law firm’s site is incredible, and I would definitely hire them for all my law-firm-related needs if they weren’t so insistently requesting the opposite.”

Yup, Even the Making of Ice Cubes Was Controversial: “The New York Daily Globe reportedly saying that same year: “There is a Dr. Gorrie, a crank, down in Florida, who thinks he can make ice as good as God Almighty.”

Valuing Mangrove Forests: “The effects are substantial in magnitude, reducing the probability of losing a quarter or more of housing value by 2-7 percentage points, which corresponds to 20-40-thousand-dollar value for a million-dollar property, conditional on a hurricane.”

The Road to Sustainable Aviation Fuel? “The lowest cost policy we study entails replacing all current biofuels policies with a modest carbon tax on fossil transportation fuels paired with a SAF tax credit.”

Permission(less) Innovation? “Permitting requirements are generally written with the assumption that the government will try to get stuff built, and so are designed to prevent the government from going too fast and skimping (perceived) critical steps like environmental review or stakeholder engagement. But there’s nothing that prevents the government from deliberately slowing down the permitting process for projects it doesn’t like. Right now this is getting weaponized against wind and solar projects, but the same tactics can easily be used against oil and gas projects”

Immigration and the Black-White Earnings Gap: “Results reveal remarkable earnings advances among 2nd-generation Black immigrants, opposite to the well-documented widening in overall Black-White earnings gap. Among women, 2nd-generation Black workers have earnings higher than or equal to White women; among men, they earn 10% less at the median, but the gap vanishes at the top decile.”

The Polarization and Profit Death Loop: “Firms’ profits are higher when they cater to workers with extreme preferences. In a competitive assignment equilibrium, firms become polarized and not only reflect but also amplify the polarized preferences of the general population. More polarized sectors exhibit higher profits, lower average wages, and a reduced labor share of value added. Sustainable investing amplifies firm polarization.” Deaths from falls among older adults have more than tripled over the past three decades. “In 2023, more than 41,000 people over 65 died after a

fall. Experts say the cause isn’t just age-related frailty; “fall risk–increasing drugs” prescribed for sleep, anxiety, pain, or heart conditions also play a major role. The proposed solution is “de-prescribing”—cutting back on unnecessary medications. In some cases, the most effective treatment may simply be deleting a few lines from the prescription.”

Why are we building the World’s Largest Transport Plane? “The world’s largest airplane, when it’s built, will stretch more than a football field from tip to tail. Sixty percent longer than the biggest existing aircraft, with 12 times as much cargo space as a 747, the behemoth will look like an oil tanker that’s sprouted wings—aeronautical engineering at a preposterous scale.”

“If the project goes through, it will enshrine Europe as the biggest energy casualty of the geopolitical earthquakes that have befallen the world over the past half-decade. In essence, the Old Continent will have traded cheap natural gas delivered via pipelines for expensive liquefied natural gas (LNG) delivered via cargo ships, predominantly from the US. The spread between those two products is a significant hurdle that will prove difficult for what remains of Europe’s heavy industries to overcome.”

Chart of the Week

“We are excited to announce the release of the Environmental Hazard Adaptation Atlas, an effort to map ongoing and future environmental hazards and their impacts on society, and to provide up to date evidence on what policies and interventions work to reduce impacts.”

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Photo of the Week

Fall in the Jay Range in the ADKs (with Great Range in the distance)

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

Film, music, cultural item of the Week

How to Stop a Bully

Image from the original Week 8 Environmental Economics course update

They Said It

“The great thieves lead away the little thief.”

– Diogenes

↑